The recent statement by Maulana Shahabuddin Razvi Barelvi, the president of the All India Muslim Jamaat, has sparked widespread controversy. His remarks, branding Indian cricketer Mohammed Shami a “criminal” for not fasting during Ramadan, have drawn mixed reactions from various sections of society.
The controversy erupted when Shami was seen consuming energy drinks during India’s semi-final match against Australia at the Dubai International Cricket Stadium. The statement has triggered a debate over the role of religious obligations in professional sports, with various religious leaders, athletes, and fans weighing in on the matter.
Maulana’s Remarks: ‘Shami is a Criminal in the Eyes of Shariat’
Speaking to the media, Maulana Shahabuddin Razvi Barelvi stated:
“Mohammed Shami has committed a sin by not fasting. He should not do this. He is a criminal in the eyes of Shariat. He will have to answer to God.”
The cleric further emphasized that fasting during Ramadan is an obligatory duty for all Muslims who are in good health. He argued that any Muslim man or woman who neglects this duty is committing a grave sin in Islam.
Mohammed Shami’s Family Defends Him
In response to the controversy, Mohammed Shami’s cousin, Mumtaz, came out in strong support of the cricketer. Speaking to the media, she stated:
“He is playing for the country. There are many Pakistani players who have not kept fast and are playing matches, so this is nothing new. It is very shameful that such things are being said about him.”
Mumtaz further urged Shami to ignore such statements and focus on his upcoming match on March 9. She reiterated that national duty should be prioritized over religious obligations, particularly in a high-stakes tournament where a player’s performance is crucial for the team’s success.
Other Religious Leaders Respond: ‘Statements Made for Cheap Publicity’
The statement by Maulana Shahabuddin Razvi Barelvi did not sit well with several religious leaders, who criticized it as unwarranted and sensationalist.
Maulana Yasoob Abbas: ‘Religion Should Not Be Forced’
Shia religious leader Maulana Yasoob Abbas strongly condemned the remarks, stating:
“The statement made by the Maulana of Bareilly is only for cheap publicity. His aim is to target Mohammed Shami. Where there is compulsion, there is no religion. Where there is religion, there is no compulsion.”
Abbas further pointed out that there are many Muslims who do not observe fasting during Ramadan, and targeting Shami alone is unjust and hypocritical.
Maulana Khalid Rashid Farangi Mahali: ‘Athletes Have the Option Not to Fast’
Another religious figure, Maulana Khalid Rashid Farangi Mahali, a member of the All India Muslim Personal Law Board, highlighted the Islamic exemption for athletes. According to him:
“Islam gives athletes the option not to fast if they are involved in physical exertion. Since Shami is playing, he has the right to defer his fast and compensate for it later.”
Public Reaction: Mixed Responses on Social Media
As the controversy gained traction, social media erupted with mixed reactions. While some users supported the cleric’s view, arguing that religious obligations should not be compromised, others defended Shami, emphasizing his dedication to the sport and the country.
Support for Shami
- Many fans and former cricketers extended their support to Shami, emphasizing that an individual’s religious practices should remain a personal matter.
- Cricket legend Virender Sehwag tweeted:
“A player’s duty is to his team and nation. Religion is a personal choice. Let sports remain free from unnecessary controversies.”
- Fans also pointed out that several other Muslim cricketers, including those from Pakistan and Bangladesh, have played without fasting during Ramadan.
Criticism from Some Religious Groups
- On the other hand, some users on social media criticized Shami, arguing that being a Muslim role model, he should set an example by following religious obligations.
Certain Islamic organizations backed Maulana Shahabuddin’s statement, claiming that Shami should have made arrangements to fast, even if he was playing.
